What is difference between replace and replaceall in javascript?

What's the difference between java.lang.String 's replace() and replaceAll() methods, other than later uses regex? For simple substitutions like, replace . with / , is there any difference?

asked May 31, 2012 at 5:24

0

In java.lang.String, the replace method either takes a pair of char's or a pair of CharSequence's (of which String is a subclass, so it'll happily take a pair of String's). The replace method will replace all occurrences of a char or CharSequence. On the other hand, the first String arguments of replaceFirst and replaceAll are regular expressions (regex). Using the wrong function can lead to subtle bugs.

x-yuri

14.3k12 gold badges100 silver badges147 bronze badges

answered May 31, 2012 at 5:28

emilanemilan

12.5k11 gold badges31 silver badges37 bronze badges

4

Q: What's the difference between the java.lang.String methods replace() and replaceAll(), other than that the latter uses regex.

A: Just the regex. They both replace all :)

http://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/lang/String.html

PS:

There's also a replaceFirst() (which takes a regex)

Manuel Jordan

14.1k19 gold badges84 silver badges135 bronze badges

answered May 31, 2012 at 5:29

paulsm4paulsm4

109k16 gold badges131 silver badges181 bronze badges

4

Both replace() and replaceAll() replace all occurrences in the String.

Examples

I always find examples helpful to understand the differences.

replace()

Use replace() if you just want to replace some char with another char or some String with another String (actually CharSequence).

Example 1

Replace all occurrences of the character x with o.

String myString = "__x___x___x_x____xx_";

char oldChar = 'x';
char newChar = 'o';

String newString = myString.replace(oldChar, newChar);
// __o___o___o_o____oo_

Example 2

Replace all occurrences of the string fish with sheep.

String myString = "one fish, two fish, three fish";

String target = "fish";
String replacement = "sheep";

String newString = myString.replace(target, replacement);
// one sheep, two sheep, three sheep

replaceAll()

Use replaceAll() if you want to use a regular expression pattern.

Example 3

Replace any number with an x.

String myString = "__1_6____3__6_345____0";

String regex = "\\d";
String replacement = "x";

String newString = myString.replaceAll(regex, replacement); 
// __x_x____x__x_xxx____x

Example 4

Remove all whitespace.

String myString = "   Horse         Cow\n\n   \r Camel \t\t Sheep \n Goat        ";

String regex = "\\s";
String replacement = "";

String newString = myString.replaceAll(regex, replacement); 
// HorseCowCamelSheepGoat

See also

Documentation

• replace(char oldChar, char newChar)
• replace(CharSequence target, CharSequence replacement)
• replaceAll(String regex, String replacement)
• replaceFirst(String regex, String replacement)

Regular Expressions

• Tutorial
• List of patterns

answered Nov 14, 2017 at 2:28

SuragchSuragch

445k286 gold badges1309 silver badges1346 bronze badges

0

The replace() method is overloaded to accept both a primitive char and a CharSequence as arguments.

Now as far as the performance is concerned, the replace() method is a bit faster than replaceAll() because the latter first compiles the regex pattern and then matches before finally replacing whereas the former simply matches for the provided argument and replaces.

Since we know the regex pattern matching is a bit more complex and consequently slower, then preferring replace() over replaceAll() is suggested whenever possible.

For example, for simple substitutions like you mentioned, it is better to use:

replace('.', '\\');

instead of:

replaceAll("\\.", "\\\\");

Note: the above conversion method arguments are system-dependent.

answered May 31, 2012 at 5:33

Surender ThakranSurender Thakran

3,75810 gold badges44 silver badges80 bronze badges

3

1. Both replace() and replaceAll() accepts two arguments and replaces all occurrences of the first substring(first argument) in a string with the second substring (second argument).
2. replace() accepts a pair of char or charsequence and replaceAll() accepts a pair of regex.

3. It is not true that replace() works faster than replaceAll() since both uses the same code in its implementation

   Pattern.compile(regex).matcher(this).replaceAll(replacement);

Now the question is when to use replace and when to use replaceAll(). When you want to replace a substring with another substring regardless of its place of occurrence in the string use replace(). But if you have some particular preference or condition like replace only those substrings at the beginning or end of a string use replaceAll(). Here are some examples to prove my point:

String str = new String("==qwerty==").replaceAll("^==", "?"); \\str: "?qwerty=="
String str = new String("==qwerty==").replaceAll("==$", "?"); \\str: "==qwerty?"
String str = new String("===qwerty==").replaceAll("(=)+", "?"); \\str: "?qwerty?"

answered Feb 17, 2016 at 6:13

AaryaAarya

3773 silver badges5 bronze badges

2

String replace(char oldChar, char newChar)

Returns a new string resulting from replacing all occurrences of oldChar in this string with newChar.

String replaceAll(String regex, String replacement

Replaces each substring of this string that matches the given regular expression with the given replacement.

Kampai

22.5k20 gold badges91 silver badges93 bronze badges

answered Apr 30, 2015 at 7:34

To throw more light with an example into how both are going to work for below code:

public static void main(String[] args)
{
    String s = "My\\s aaab\\s is\\s aaab\\s name";
    String s1 = s.replace("\\s", "c");
    System.out.println(s1);
    String s2 = s.replaceAll("\\s", "c");
    System.out.println(s2);
}

Output:

Myc aaabc isc aaabc name
My\scaaab\scis\scaaab\scname

Explanation

s.replace replaces "\\s" sequence of characters with c. Hence, the output in first line. s.replaceAll considers \\s as a regex rather(equivalent to space) and replaces spaces with c. \\s in String s is escaped with first \ encountered and becomes \s.

Intellij Idea is smart enough to notify you of the usage as well. If you take a closer look at below image, you will see the difference in interpretation by Intellij idea for replace and replaceAll usage.

answered May 24, 2021 at 8:37

KnockingHeadsKnockingHeads

1,0031 gold badge14 silver badges36 bronze badges

Old thread I know but I am sort of new to Java and discover one of it's strange things. I have used String.replaceAll() but get unpredictable results.

Something like this mess up the string:

sUrl = sUrl.replaceAll( "./", "//").replaceAll( "//", "/");

So I designed this function to get around the weird problem:

//String.replaceAll does not work OK, that's why this function is here
public String strReplace( String s1, String s2, String s ) 
{
    if((( s == null ) || (s.length() == 0 )) || (( s1 == null ) || (s1.length() == 0 )))
     { return s; }

   while( (s != null) && (s.indexOf( s1 ) >= 0) )
    { s = s.replace( s1, s2 ); }
  return s;
}

Which make you able to do:

sUrl=this.strReplace("./", "//", sUrl );
sUrl=this.strReplace( "//", "/", sUrl );

answered Mar 22, 2014 at 13:18

CodebeatCodebeat

6,4016 gold badges54 silver badges93 bronze badges

3

As alluded to in wickeD's answer, with replaceAll the replacement string is handled differently between replace and replaceAll. I expected a[3] and a[4] to have the same value, but they are different.

public static void main(String[] args) {
    String[] a = new String[5];
    a[0] = "\\";
    a[1] = "X";
    a[2] = a[0] + a[1];
    a[3] = a[1].replaceAll("X", a[0] + "X");
    a[4] = a[1].replace("X", a[0] + "X");

    for (String s : a) {
        System.out.println(s + "\t" + s.length());
    }
}

The output of this is:

\   1
X   1
\X  2
X   1
\X  2

This is different from perl where the replacement does not require the extra level of escaping:

#!/bin/perl
$esc = "\\";
$s = "X";

$s =~ s/X/${esc}X/;
print "$s " . length($s) . "\n";

which prints \X 2

This can be quite a nuisance, as when trying to use the value returned by java.sql.DatabaseMetaData.getSearchStringEscape() with replaceAll().

answered Feb 24, 2017 at 21:58

replace() method doesn't uses regex pattern whereas replaceAll() method uses regex pattern. So replace() performs faster than replaceAll().

justcurious

8373 gold badges12 silver badges29 bronze badges

answered Jun 10, 2015 at 7:07

amanaman

1351 silver badge12 bronze badges

2

To add to the already selected "Best Answer" (and others that are just as good like Suragch's), String.replace() is constrained by replacing characters that are sequential (thus taking CharSequence). However, String.replaceAll() is not constrained by replacing sequential characters only. You could replace non-sequential characters as well as long as your regular expression is constructed in such a way.

Also (most importantly and painfully obvious), replace() can only replace literal values; whereas replaceAll can replace 'like' sequences (not necessarily identical).

answered Jan 7, 2020 at 21:28

hfontanezhfontanez

5,1912 gold badges25 silver badges34 bronze badges

replace works on char data type but replaceAll works on String datatype and both replace the all occurrences of first argument with second argument.

answered May 31, 2012 at 5:35

Pramod KumarPramod Kumar

7,7665 gold badges27 silver badges37 bronze badges

What is the difference between Replace () and replaceAll ()?

What is replaceAll in JavaScript?

What is $1 in replace JavaScript?

When was replaceAll added to JavaScript?